Most of the reviews that I have read regarding "The
Dreamers" make comparisons between it and
Bertolucci's masterpiece from 1972, Last Tango in Paris
which starred Marlon Brando. There are indeed
several similarities between the two, notwithstanding the
nudity and sex that permeates much of the second half of
"The Dreamers". Both stories take place
mostly in a large apartment in Paris involving characters
who have troubling secrets and participate in sudden
sexual games with strangers. However, whereas Last
Tango in Paris was a mesmerizing psychological tragedy
involving loss and grief, this film doesn't have the
similar powerful impact and emotion that the former did.
An American named Matthew arrives in Paris during the late
1960's to study French at the university. Matthew is an
avid film buff and spends as much time as possible at the
French cinema. He meets up with twins Isabelle and
Theo who also seem to spend most of their time at the
movies as well. Soon, the twins invite Matthew over
for dinner at their house with them and their parents.
It turns out that the parents are leaving the next day for
a month-long trip and after they go, Isabelle and Theo
invite Matt to stay with them instead of the hotel that he
is currently living in.
Matthew finds out quickly that the twins like to play
movie quiz games with the loser having to submit to a
forfeit dare by the other one. Of course, these
games just happen to involve sexual acts. Theo is
forced to masturbate by Isabella in front of a picture of
Garbo and when Isabelle and Matthew are deemed losers by
Theo, he commands them to have sex in front of him.
Matthew is at first scared and reluctant to do this but
succumbs to the pressure by the other two and before we
know it, he has fallen in love with Isabelle. As
these sexual games continue, the stakes get higher and
higher as just outside their window, a cultural revolution
is taking place with big fights between the people and the
police.
There are many pleasures to get from this film. For
film buffs, there are many references to scenes from other
movies and some of these are acted out by Isabella who
wants Matthew to guess what film she is acting out the
scene from. And Bertollucci does a neat thing here as
well. He splices into the film in black and white
footage, many of the movie scenes that the characters are
talking about or acting out. There is no doubt that
this film can be characterized as beautiful to watch.
So, what is missing from this film? I thought the
story started out to be very interesting and when the
sexual games started to be played, I wanted to know where
it was going to take these three people. But by the
end of the film, it just didn't have the impact or emotion
tied to it that I was expecting. Without this more
powerful aspect to the story, the sexual and mind games
being played seem to be trivialized to a certain point.
Whereas in Last Tango in Paris, the audience could feel
the pain and anguish that the Brando character was going
through, there was no similar experience with "The
Dreamers". Although I believe I may have picked up on
some subtle hints that possibly some darker things had
happened to Isabella, but I may be stretching there.
So in conclusion, even though I liked this film enough to
easily recommend it, I still found it to be somewhat
disappointing at the same time. Maybe I was looking
for an equally powerful movie like Last Tango and just
didn't find it. Many viewers will no doubt be
appalled by the nudity in this film, but just like in Last
Tango, the nudity and sex is natural and an important part
to the story, and not gratuitous by any means.
Society seems to cringe at nudity and sensuality but
totally embrace excessive violence that is shown in films.
And maybe Bertolucci is making a statement about this with
artistic films like this.